Saturday, January 24, 2009

Unit 1: Scholasticism, Prelude to Modernism

Question #1

The scholastic way of doing philosophy varies depending on the author’s intent. For example, lets say that a scholar teaches theories of past philosophers (Plato, Socrates, Hobbes, etc) to a group of student. Therefore, the scholar would need to know that text completely before teaching it. The only real differences between scholastics of the past versus the present vary in the methods. Lectio would be a flawed approach to using scholastics, due to the lack of questioning on the part of the students. What if in a scenario, the scholar explains something based off their intuition/innate perception of that piece of text without any ambiguity. Or what if the scholar only wants to talk about certain parts (dependant) of the text without mentioning parts of others. Alternatively, what if the scholar tends to be dogmatic in their teaching methods. See how easy it would be to misunderstand the truth about that subject.
Now Disputatio on the other hand is the proper way to teach through scholastics. Specifically quodlibetal, which give the students power to question the scholar’s knowledge on that subject. This process is evident in passing on the knowledge of philosophy & science to future generations. Questions alone allow students to evolve in there though processes, giving them a better understanding of what philosophy is all about. After all, if we didn’t question everything we still to this day would believe: that the sun revolves around the earth, the earth itself is flat as a pancake, and that Sinbad the Comedian is still funny!


Question #2

According to Bonaventure’s theory, he supported that truth can emerge from rational argumentation only when the methods of philosophy are illuminated by religious faith. Claiming that God by faith can guide humans towards the truth. While Aquinas believed in the Dominican order that focus more on the Aristotelian materials. His take is humans rely more on sensory information for acquiring knowledge of the world.

Personally, I think Aquinas point makes more logical sense, while Bonaventure tends to be flawed for the most part. If Bonaventure main premise is that God created humanity, and that Christian Doctrine is the only way to find complete truth of things. It seems on the borderline of “False Choice” if you ask me! I want to use a personal experience for comparison of a counter argument. There were various attempts by family and friends to convert me to faith over a twenty-year period, which I do not believe in any religion at this point in my life. They had me attend church services, go on summer campouts, and even my aunt made me say a couple of sentences (like the Muslim pledge) giving my life the Jesus Christ in front of a mirror. I emotional feel uncomfortable about the concepts of religion, hence why I choose not to believe in it. If God created me in his image, it is practical for God to program my soul to accept Christianity without question. On top of that, why would you want to be dependent one person for all the answers anyway?

We are born into this world without knowing anything at the start of life. Therefore, we struggle to find out more about things through “trial-and error.” Moreover, eventually we do find the truth of things. Much like what Aquinas advocates about being objected about truth, compared to faith.


Question #3

The church’s attitude was very straightforward; criticize other philosophers and society, but not God or the church itself! This is evident with the cases of Giordano and Galileo. Giordano was executed for negative remarks about Christianity, despite the stance he had against astronomy. Galileo faced ridicule for challenging the theory of Nicholas Copernicus. Tommaso has defended the notion that God was the center for all truth and doctrine regarding humanity. When the Spanish imprisoned Tommaso in 1603, Pope Paul V made the effort to free him from captivity. At this point, it is clear that the church become more concern about protecting the ideology, rather than investigating the facts. “Power over Truth” can sum up this scenario as a whole.


Question #4

The main “Problem of Universals” has to do with Universals themselves. If Universals predict the relations of individuals, what about changes of qualities that occur over a period of time. Lets say that Rob, Mike, and Freddy represent a Universal of males. They all are Republicans and enlist in the US Army. Rob is stationed in South Korea, while Mike is serving in Iraq, and Freddy ends up in Afghanistan, A year-and-a-half later they all return home. Rob turns out to be OK, Mike has lost his left arm and has a badly scarred face, and Freddy has lost both of his legs in an IED attack. Now focus on physical qualities, would they still be categorized as Universals at this point?

Realism claims that Universals are real entities and they exist independent of particulars. While Nominalism, assert that only individuals or particulars exist and denies that universals are real. Rob, Mike, and Freddy association as Republicans would be an example of Realism. Let say that when they come back home, Rob stays a Republican, but Mike changes over to a Democrat, and Freddy an Independent. Wouldn’t this categorize as Nominalism too?


Please forgive me not being able to answer Question 5. I ran out of time trying to answer the other four, maybe another student will have an answer to that one ;)

2 comments:

  1. Comment by Kristal (Posted by Young)

    I particularly enjoyed reading your response to the fourth question regarding nominalism and realism, and the analogy of the three men actually helped me understand the assigned text better. I believe that the modern answer to the Problem of Universals is Conceptualism, although it is described as a type of nominalism on the Wikipedia site. I also enjoyed reading about your thoughts on religion, and believe that "trial-and-error" is an effective way of getting through life. You never know that fire really burns until you put your hand over the flame. Physical and emotional scars are really the things that help us in future situations, as opposed to reciting a verse from a book that someone else wrote about someone else's situation. Great job! - Kristal

    ReplyDelete
  2. Just a quick comment on the bit about republicans changing their party. Republicans changing allegiance cannot be nominalism. nominalism is a doctrine about the existence or nonexistence of universals. It says nothing about events in the physical world. Political allegiance is not a natural quality, so the scholastics wouldn't think it was a universal in the sense that "green" and "horse" are universals.

    ReplyDelete