Sunday, May 10, 2009
Unit 6: George Berkeley
2. Berkeley thought that trying to refer to objects as “real” or “material” was confusing and pointless. Since he claims that our only real experiences of objects throughout our lives comes directly from perceptions. And that we should refer to saying the term “perceived objects” is more appropriate in that manner. So that we can describe it through details and descriptions. Let me give an example with this printed piece of paper in front of me. My perceptions are that it has square edges, mostly white with black type letters on the surface. It has a smooth texture with rough edges. But my mind also perceives it as light and crumpled based on the appearance. So would appearance be the key word to perception?
3. He states that the existence of other people all depend on something known as “objective.” What does it mean to be “objective?” The dictionary says “having actual existence outside the mind.” But obviously this is too vague an explanation. What about combining both of the words to form “perceived objective?” Afterall, you can analysis a person based on your observations, while taking into consideration their existence outside of your mind. Couldn’t this provide some sort of balance or a bridge in figuring out what exists and what doesn’t?
4. I think that Berkeley notices other people’s perceptions are similar to his own in many ways. He knew that other people have asked the same questions independently of himself. Thus when he talks about “speak to him” is when people share their insights about the world. And that they used the same type of perceptions gives a consistent answer in the process. Put it this way; let’s say that you go to a Bar on a Saturday alone. Then later you mingle with other people that you’ve never see before. You have perceptions about what makes a good relationship in your mind. But another person speaks about that subject first by giving their insights as well. And you realize that his/her insights are similar to yours. Thus providing the consistency that Berkeley mentions.
5. Berkeley overall views are that the presence of God is the perquisite for all of our life experiences to take place. Then he uses the analogy that God is a tree growing in a quadrangle at a University (humanity and the world.) And that the tree continues to exist despite of the people’s presence of it. Hence God has an infinite mind that can perceive everything. Forgive me for using some Logic for a moment. But do God and a tree really go together? God is an immortal divine being, and a tree is a mortal organism. God would have supernatural powers, while the tree is an immobile object. God creates life and the universe (supposedly,) and the tree creates leaves, bark, and oxygen. Do these two things really have anything in common at this point? Sounds like a False Analogy if you ask me!
6. Dr. Johnson who was infuriated by Berkeley’s theory kicked a heavy stone followed by the quote “I refute it thus!” Claiming that this physical activity proves the existence based on his perceptions. Dr. Johnson fails to realize that what the stone consisted of in reality was different in the construction of its perception. In other words, it was an idea that originated in the mind pure and simple. Besides, you can’t just kick a stone and expect to prove your point just like that. Sounds like a combination if Begging the Question, and insecurities to accepting a new theory.
7. Locke perceived that a primary quality is more of a physical characteristic of the substance itself. Compared to the secondary quality is more of a sensorial perception of the object. Not to forget that a secondary quality end up augmenting, but isn’t part of the objects substance altogether.
8. Locke uses three buckets of water which are cold, lukewarm, and hot. He says to put one hand into the cold and the other hand into the hot buckets. Then a few moments later put both hands in the lukewarm bucket. Both of your hand (objects) should determine if the water is “Hot or Cold,” but you find out that the water is both “Hot and Cold” at the same time. This basically points out that the temperature is a temporary characteristic that can easily change from one to another. As to why Locke says this count as a secondary quality of the water.
9. Berkeley extends primary qualities in the similar fashion of Locke. He points out that shape is a secondary quality because the size depends on the distance between the observer and the object. The difference in size can easily change, much like the temperature of the water in the buckets. But then Berkeley goes all out and refutes shape because he says it is neither primary nor secondary qualities.
10. Personality, I still don’t think that God can exist despite the perceiving part or not. This also reminds me of those Ghost Hunters reality TV Shows. And there attempts to perceive the existence of ghosts. But they put too much emphasis due to the fact that they’re dependent on finding ghosts. What about other factors that can mislead your perceptions of something. Let’s say that one of this Ghost Hunter’s walk into certain of a room and feel increased heat and start to get sweaty. Could that experience be perceived as a Ghost? What if you were standing near a heat vent? Or had hot-flashes? Or the room has poor ventilation or is over-insulation? IF those are the cases, then it seems more like secondary qualities. Since it’s just a temporary event, and not part of the permanent markup of that phenomenon. So what Berkeley says he perceives God as a present entity, what does he specifically perceive in order to make that happen?
11. Maybe our perceptions of humanity and the world around us serve as an example to figure out what life is all about. Since us humans have a tendency to experience and analysis our lives in an innate fashion. We’re all trying to understand our existence and purpose from an individual’s Point-Of-View. Here’s a random question: What if the shape of the human body and the personality of the mind end up as a universal law or quality? And when we perceive other people that it might become a mirror of some sort? And that we see ourselves through others in this manner? Well, this is my best guess to this million dollar question on philosophy for now.
Monday, April 27, 2009
Rene Descartes: Part 3
19. The so called “problem” with the mind-body is not about creating a solution for the concept. But Descartes then claim that the mind and body are connected to each other. This lead to a logical contradiction to Cartesian Dualism that claims that it’s the complete opposite of one another. Or how can the mind (immaterial) control the body (material) in the first place? And it almost sounds like Begging the Question by the lack of an answer from Descartes. So let me ask this question about the mind in particular. When he talks about “the mind,” is it about the brain (organ) itself? Or is it about other aspects of the brain such as the consciousness/sub-consciousness? If that’s the case, it seems like a 50/50 situation in regards to being either material or non-material. Maybe Descartes assumed more on the consciousness/sub-consciousness part perhaps?
20. Physicalism is a concept about any kind of thing that can be seen, felt, picked up. There were ideas on what to call the thing which leads to the word “matter.” Later on it changed to “materialism” as a way to say that matter can exist. This also distinguishes the notion that supernatural beings cannot exist because they’re not made of matter. But supernatural forces were mistakenly categorized as being until Einstein claimed that those forces (energy) were matter since they obeyed the laws of physics. Physicalism would make sense on earth, but what about the confines of outer space? Is a vacuum like a black hole considered matter? Logically, black holes are anti-matter, since it can break down matter in a heartbeat. Is celestial beings matter too, or is it just patterns of gas? I think it all boils down to the characteristics in terms of dimensional qualities that should be look at to determine if it is matter or not?
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
Rene Descartes: Part 2
12. Descartes main reason that we cannot accept knowledge through our senses has to do possibility of the Evil Genius. He uses this entity as a way to marry doubt with reason. So that you question the possibilities of something interfering with your senses. Dreams are a very good example, since they create experiences that might be real, but only after waking up and realizing that nothing tangible took place. If there is something that cannot be logically false, how do you know that to be true? Hence, if there’s more doubt than certainty with a subject, chances are that it might be false.
13. The reason that Descartes cannot be dependent on Mathematics for finding knowledge. Again, this is due to the possibility of the senses being fooled, even with the case of basis elementary mathematical operations. I think this is relevant to my experiences with Math classes as well. Keep in mind that Mathematics is the metaphor of a tree trunk that has specific branches extending from it. Moreover, since Math Instructors introduce tons of symbols, formulas, and processes that can be hard to comprehend sensorial. The “absolute value” is a good example to compare. If you see two vertical lines on either side of integer, how do you know that it is not something else? On the other hand, what about using dots for multiplication, how can you distinguish it as that. How do you know that it is not decimal instead? Since both can be used in close proximity of the same space, which can easily confuse your visual sense of what that really is for. Or how about that news article on Yahoo recently about a surgeon that mistakenly removes fatty tissue instead of an appendix from a patient. Do you think that surgeon senses possibly tricked him into taking the wrong organ?
14. This phrase is to provide that having thoughts is evidence that Descartes proves his existence. Let alone, that the mind itself can exist too, based on the use of ideas. In addition, these ideas have innate qualities that allow you to recognize or even label other tangible objects outside of the human body. Not to forget that your mind can work and create innate ideas independently of your body. Do I really need to use any part of my body (including senses) to make octopuppies? I obviously cannot create an octopuppie using my body, since it is logically impossible to make tentacles or flesh of one. Maybe using genetic engineering (gene splicing) that could become a reality, if Doctor Young wants to lobby Washington to make it happen.
15. Descartes tries to use the wax as a way to prove innate ideas. This is the complete opposite of Plato’s argument that innate ideas are unreliable to be used for knowledge. Therefore, Descartes takes the solid piece of wax and explores it through his senses. He is able to understand the properties (smell, texture, color, etc) after playing with it for a while. Then the wax is moved near the fireplace, which causes it to melt. As it melts, the wax properties change completely during the transition. Therefore, the melted wax has nothing in common with the solid wax at this point. Therefore, Descartes realizes that it is unreliable in using your senses to identify the wax. Hence, he says the innate ideas are the only way to determine that it is wax, in spite of what physical condition it might be. This may sound like a silly use of Descartes Wax Argument, but this can be related to movie THE THING (1982) by the filmmaker John Carpenter. The movie takes place at a U.S. Scientific Outpost in Antarctica. An alien that can imitate all life-forms flawlessly (might even imitate a octopuppie) penetrates the Outpost. It eventually disguises itself as one of the humans at the Outpost. The others discover the presence of the alien, but cannot use their senses in detecting who it is. Only with innate ideas, they can flush out the alien altogether. If you have not seen that film yet, then either rent it on Netflix or buy it on Amazon, a classic piece of sci-fi indeed!
16. Descartes concept of perfection originates in the mind. Yet, perfection could not be obtained through other means because not everything in the world including him is perfect. Therefore, perfection has to have come from an innate idea. He uses reason in determining what could be categorized as perfect. So the “perfect being” that he states can only be the existence of God. Thus creating a bridge between philosophy and religion. I think that perfect is a flawed innate idea. Does it have to be dependent on the idea of something being flawless? And why would God be considered a perfect being despite that his/her creations (human beings) are capable of doing imperfect actions? Moreover, why would humanity use it as a standard for which people cannot reach?
17. Descartes begins by saying that the physical world cannot exist, since our senses can be tricked into believing there is one. But Descartes then reverses himself with rationalism, which states some sensory information can be reliable enough to use. This raises an interesting question for me to ask about this process. Why do we have senses for anyway? What is the purpose in having them for in life? It seems that we need senses as a form of interaction with the world. Wouldn’t interaction be counted as a form of knowledge?
Saturday, April 11, 2009
Unit 5: Rene Descartes
1. Wikipedia interprets Descartes quote it as the core principle is that one must seek not only to build on old foundations of knowledge, but should look for other fertile land to build knowledge upon. My interpretation of the quote has to do with acknowledging. In addition, the word “conduct” refers to how to go about recognizing it. The second part “and learned upon principles which, in my youth, I had taken upon trust” has to do with learning how to think at an early age (childhood.) And that its very easy to be fooled during that period since your mind is a blank slate which lacks the ability to determine what’s right and wrong. Moreover, that we have to “trust” the adults’ principles as is, meaning that you accept the basic norms of thinking without thinking about it thoroughly. The main flaw with the Wikipedia interpretation assumes that it is about knowledge alone. They fail to realize that thinking and knowledge are two separate, rather than just one subject. This reminds me of the old Greek metaphor about the archer and the bull’s-eye. The archer represents a person and their thinking process, while the bull’s-eye represents knowledge. If the archer cannot see (think) the bull’s-eye with a clean and precise perspective, chances are he/she will either miss or inaccurately hit the bull’s-eye. So the process is more important than the principles overall.
2. The first precept has to do with doubt itself. That you do not accept something without fully understanding what it is. Anything that has a lot of doubt tends to be more problematic than useful. Therefore, their needs to be a fine line between what is doubtful and certain when it comes to establishing knowledge. The second precept has to do with taking something apart is sections with the difficulties to have a solution. Logically, this makes sense because it is easier to get more specific on what those difficulties are, and to take the next step. The third precept is to find the simplest problem and start from that point. In addition, you keep ascending until you reach the complex ones. Finally, the fourth precept, which is to take all the information at relay it to lists, tables, and diagrams. To get all your ducks in a row so the information is complete.
3. It seems that personal life experiences are the link between religion and the scientific method. Descartes provides the example through his actions. He takes things for granted with Catholicism until the death of his daughter. Then he had doubts about the church since they act so absolute about life and the world in general. Descartes decides to question things more critically that leads to more better techniques and processes.
4. The great controversy has to do with the lack of balances between faith and reason. In addition, the Descartes action to break with Catholic doctrine possibly alienates the religious community. This created two camps (religion versus science) that to this day still try to claim the ultimate truth. From my perspective your always going to have people on both sides who are hardcore, and lack an open mind towards other possibilities. This reminds me of the saying “if both eyes are too concentrated on one are, you lose sight of all other areas in the process.”
5. Descartes Cartesian method threatened the monopoly of the church power during that period. This resulted in the constant debate between faith and reason that leads to more thoughts that are modern. His method became such an epidemic for society that moved people away from religion and more towards secularism. Nevertheless, this also created a number of religious fundamental groups who use extreme measures to prove their premises, which results in death and destruction.
6. The word modernity seems more of a trendy and even a bit of a façade when it comes to an explanation of the modern period. Is there really such a thing as “modernity?” Sounds like more about being Politically Correct than giving an accurate comparison. A better one would be progressive and traditionalism. Progressive is all about evolving in thought and not taking things for granted. Compared to traditionalism, where old ideas and methods are preserved from past scholars, establishments, and doctrines. However, the only trap of traditionalism is that people stop questioning and assume those ideas. Especially with the case of religion, since it’s all about complying with an ideology, regardless of the flaws and shortcomings in it.
7. Shorto’s thinks that the modest proposal to ground knowledge has to do with human reason, and that the Cartesian method was the basis for the scientific method and the reason-based political philosophy of the Enlightenment. First off, what is this so called “ground knowledge?” The word ground could imply established, but what is established specifically? It looks a little on the Begging the Question side so far. Moreover, why does Shorto keep thinking that Descartes was responsible for the Scientific Method? If we can review the past philosophers from this online class, it was Galileo who came up with the Scientific Method going back over two centuries. In addition, we can go further back a couple of Millennia with Aristotle too. Descartes ended up augmenting the Scientific Method with new idea only.
8. Latin was the primary dialect of the Catholic Church. Chances are if it were published in Latin, it would have interference with the church, maybe either being censored or parts of it omitted like past philosophers. Another has to do with the scholars’ verses society. If scholars have a tendency to discuss knowledge only among them then it would stay within that elite group of people. By publishing it in French allow the Discourse to be circulated on a massive scale that puts copies in the hands of individuals to comprehend and question their society. Therefore, the social effect of this tipped the balance of power away from the Status Quo, gave new ways on how to think, analysis, and distinguished what is truthful in relation to doubt.
9. Shorto’s interpretation tends to focus the examples of Descartes, in particular of the failures and tragedy of his life. He claims that the death of Descartes daughter became a revelation on how to look at the role of the nature of human beings. Realizing that all previous knowledge was unreliable, Descartes uses doubt as a tool to test in search of truth. And the thinking process (I think, therefore I am) he created made people be less dependent on the church in seeking answers.
10. Overall, Shorto’s views and arguments with Descartes are pithy in relation to the whole picture of this philosopher. Shorto tends to focus too much on the personal side along with the aftermath of his remains. Trying to make it into a romantic melodrama type story instead of getting down to the nitty-gritty rational details of Descartes theories. Even the part about where and how Descartes bones ended up decades after his death is very unfortunate ending. Scientist and Philosophers treating the bones and especially the skull as if they were sacred and profane objects, WTF Man! Descartes was a Great Philosopher for his time, but he was not a Divine being! If there is a blotch in the history of Science, this affair could be counted as one. Talking about superstition all over again, yikes!
Sunday, March 8, 2009
Unit 4: Thomas Hobbes
62. Hobbes thinks that if there were a lack of sovereign authority, people would just end up going into anarchy. Since its “make up the rules as you go” type of demeanor. Criminals are free to steal, rape, kill, and do other heinous acts without ramifications. Forgive me for using this recent example, but have you ever seen those Judge TV shows? If you have, imagine if there was no Judge, Guards, or Courtroom, do you think that the two parties could settle their disputes in a civilized manner? Personally, I think that one would outsmart the other and right and wrong goes out the window. Hobbes says logically, a lack of control or order results in matters getting out of hand and falling by the wayside. Hobbes believes humans cannot be trusted to come together and do the right thing in that particular scenario.
63. Hobbes says that the fundamental justification for people founding a Commonwealth is the fact that individuals would not be able to depend on their passions and ambitions to secure a livelihood. In order for this to work, the individuals have to enter into an agreement (contract) to give up all their interest in the process. So, a state of neutrality is needed for the Commonwealth to form.
64. The contracting parties are the human beings themselves. Sovereign is not involved in the contract. Because you need a consensus on what kind of social order and government before sovereignty can take place. Hobbes thinks that loopholes will be created (right of nature) if not all of the details are worked out before hand.
65. Hobbes claims that the political legitimacy of a sovereign power all boils down to the way it functions. If the government fails to protect its citizens from physical harm, how can it expect to protect the social order in the long run. The social covenant for lack of trust would break down, and goes back to square one, or the state of nature. Perhaps Hobbes reasoning ends up as a caveat which can be plainly said “Don’t F*** it up!”
66. Hobbes believes that power should never be divided. He thinks that it must have absolute authority to be effective. If all entities of government (legislation, adjudication, enforcement, taxation, war-making, etc) fail to work as one, it could caused a breakdown of social order that leads to a civil war according to Hobbes.
67. Hobbes does not believe that power should be limited. He says that people can use it as a reprieve to allow them to challenge the government. In addition, that can lead to non-authoritative ‘authorities.’ The analogy of cancer cells that form inside the human body is a perfect way to put it concisely. Since cancer only cares about growing in size, with no regard for the integrity of all the other vital organs. And it does not stop until it has inhabited the whole human body. Hobbes just reiterates that absolute authority is the way to go with the Commonwealth in order for it to work.
Saturday, February 7, 2009
Unit 3: Sir Francis Bacon
1. Bacon tries to get at the inner workings of nature in terms of how the order is produced with the interplay of matter and motions of it.
2. The forms mean the process of investigating variable and particular causes with the latter reflecting on general and constant ones specifically.
3. The “Idols of the Tribe” is the false concepts due to human nature in regards to learning something. An example of this could be assumptions of bias regarding a subject. Like an American saying after 9/11, “we should just drop a nuclear bomb on the middle east because the ways of Islam only incite violence.”
4. The “Idols of the Cave” consist of conceptions or doctrines, which are dear to the individual who cherishes them, without possessing any evidence of their truth. Religious people are one perfect example of this. Or the former Bush Administration claim that Iraq had “weapons of mass destruction” at the UN, only to find out after the invasion we learned that Saddam didn’t have any. Not to forget that W wanted to avenge his father’s failed assanitation attempt by Hussein in 1994. Along with helping, the Neo-Cons secure more resources (namely oil) in the Middle East.
5. The “Idols of the Market Place” are false conceptions, which are derived from public human communication. Here is a classic example of this, Former President Bush (Thank God) little comments such as “they hate us for our freedom” or “if we don’t beat them there they’ll follow us home.” In addition, the infamous “We thought that oceans could protect us!”
6. The “Idols of the Theater” are prejudices stemming from received or traditional philosophical system, which were never exposed to an experimental check or to a test by experience. “Intelligent design” is one of those philosophies that is taught in some public schools, but has never been allowed to be tested to see if it holds up. A textbook example if you ask me.
7. The table of presence is where phenomena exist whose formal cause is sought. Water for example appears to be present in oceans, glaciers, steam, etc.
8. The table of absence is where phenomena under analysis do not appear to be present. There appears to be no water in the upper edges of the earth’s atmosphere.
9. The table of degrees lists the increase of decrease of a given phenomenon in one object or in different objects. An example would be the decrease of CFC’s in the past 20 years has lead to an increase of O3 molecules in the ozone layer.
10. The Baconian Method is a series of individual methods (agreement, difference, conconcomitant variation) that are used to isolate or find the cause of a phenomenon.
11. Bacon believed that Aristotle lack a master principle or general theory of science that could be applied to all branches of natural history and philosophy.
12. Bacon’s method was a way to evolve the scientific process from previous ancient to renaissance philosophers. Adding new knowledge like the inductive method, the use of Idols to detect fallacies, as well as diversifying natural science by splitting it into physics and metaphysics.
Saturday, January 31, 2009
Unit 2: Galileo, A Pioneer of Modern Thinking
2. The premise of Ockham’s Razor states that when dealing with a series of explanations; the one explanation that has a simpler or fewer assumptions can end up the more accurate one. As to why he emphasis “entities must not be multiplied beyond necessity" in order for it to work.
3. Ockham’s razor would definitely ax the part “where universals are repeatable or recurrent entities that can be instantiated or exemplified by many particular things.” Especially for the words (repeatable or recurrent) which lack the simplicity of answers. The qualities or characteristics (types or kinds, properties, relations) would logically remain in the process. You could say, “Yellow Lab doge tend to have a friendly personality around humans” which provides a simple explanation for the subject. Instead of a flawed one like “Yellow Lab dogs tend to have a friendly personality around humans because of their past. Perhaps this is due to where they originally came from. The doge must have learned to be humane from the harsh winter of Canada. This forced them to bond with humans and understand how to be obedient. This also must make them more domesticated than any other breed of dog on the planet.” Talk about a big SLASH from the razor on this one huh?
4. I think what Ockham was trying to point out with “mere Belief”; has to do with our mental or innate interpretations of something we feel is right. Moreover, when we only see things from a certain viewpoint, then it makes other interpretations of that subject impossible. Hence why Ockham points out that Universals are dependant on our mental concept of it, which shows why it does not work so well in the physical realm (reality) aspect of it all.
5. Epistemology is one Ockham’s important idea that carried on into British Philosophy in terms of establishing true knowledge.
6. Nicholas of Autrecourt claimed that Scholasticism was obsolete, due to fact that philosophical reasoning was not working. This allowed other rational methods to be employed in the teaching process.
7. They would use rational methods to generate paradoxical results, demonstrating the need to rely upon the so-called “mystical union with god as the foundation for genuine human knowledge. In other words, this method got their disciples to question things in a critical manner.
8. By trying to embrace contradiction of medieval philosophy. It did not work due to the fact of contradiction alone. If one fact clashed with another, what are we left with, NOTHING! Maybe Nicolas of Cusa should have embraced the flaws of medieval philosophy, if there were any?
9. Galileo rejected the part of Copernicanism where the earth was at the center of our solar system (sun revolves around the earth).
10. Using his telescope, Galileo proved that the sun itself is at the center of our solar system.
11. The reason for Galileo having many enemies has to do with questioning Scripture passages. Particularly Psalm 93:1, 96:10, 104:5, and Chronicles 16:30. Not to mention that the fact he was heavily involved into Astronomy, and created Heliocentrism this is a contradiction of the Catholic Churches Ideology.
12. Galileo was remembered for his contribution to the Scientific Revolution, particular to the breakthrough in physics, mathematics, and astronomy.
13. Galileo’s main contribution to science was the telescope, astronomical observations, along with college physics courses, and improved compass designs.
14. Galileo infuriated the Aristotleans with his theory of falling bodies, which debunked the falsity of the peripatetic maxim, hitherto accepted without question, that their rate of descent is proportional to their weight.
15. The Aristotlean reaction demonstrates there pre-modern theory of heavy objects falls quicker regardless of the rate of decent. Versus Galileo’s modern theory, which points out that rate of decent of a falling object is linked with the proportional part of their weight.
16. Galileo offered no definite theory of the nature of comments, despite the tentative conjectures that he offers which later turned out to be false. Not to forget that Galileo made some Ad Hominems about Jesuit Christopher Scheiner and the professors at Collegio Romano.
17. Galileo stated that the laws of nature are mathematical. As a philosopher, Galileo says the universe was written in the language of mathematics (triangles, circles, geometry.)
18. The “theory of tides” were caused by the slashing back and fourth of water in the seas as a point on the Earth’s surface speeded up and slowed down because of the Earth’s rotation on its axis and revolution around the sun, according to Galileo.
19. It turned out that position and gravitational field of the moon at various times of the day caused tides, according to Johannes Kepler.
20. Because Galileo took a calculate risk with his theory. Not to mention the fact that other people like Albert Einstein could challenge these theories, and make new ones based off more evidence that is reliable. In other words, no one became dependant off knowledge of the past.