11. Descartes saw previous philosophical methods that were considered either too primitive or obsolete with other philosophers before him. Being an expert in Mathematics, Descartes thought that applying the foundations and rigors of Mathematics would at least give philosophy some structure. And would also provide some processes of reasoning that would eventually tell you if something is true of false. Descartes also says that from a position of knowledge, you must start out by knowing nothing. Because most people will try to claim an absolute truth to knowledge, but only to find out through a process of investigation that they do not know anything too! Not to forget that Descartes was the first to create the so called “Powerful through Experiment” like the Evil Genius as a way to challenge the epistemological premise of acquiring knowledge through your senses.
12. Descartes main reason that we cannot accept knowledge through our senses has to do possibility of the Evil Genius. He uses this entity as a way to marry doubt with reason. So that you question the possibilities of something interfering with your senses. Dreams are a very good example, since they create experiences that might be real, but only after waking up and realizing that nothing tangible took place. If there is something that cannot be logically false, how do you know that to be true? Hence, if there’s more doubt than certainty with a subject, chances are that it might be false.
13. The reason that Descartes cannot be dependent on Mathematics for finding knowledge. Again, this is due to the possibility of the senses being fooled, even with the case of basis elementary mathematical operations. I think this is relevant to my experiences with Math classes as well. Keep in mind that Mathematics is the metaphor of a tree trunk that has specific branches extending from it. Moreover, since Math Instructors introduce tons of symbols, formulas, and processes that can be hard to comprehend sensorial. The “absolute value” is a good example to compare. If you see two vertical lines on either side of integer, how do you know that it is not something else? On the other hand, what about using dots for multiplication, how can you distinguish it as that. How do you know that it is not decimal instead? Since both can be used in close proximity of the same space, which can easily confuse your visual sense of what that really is for. Or how about that news article on Yahoo recently about a surgeon that mistakenly removes fatty tissue instead of an appendix from a patient. Do you think that surgeon senses possibly tricked him into taking the wrong organ?
14. This phrase is to provide that having thoughts is evidence that Descartes proves his existence. Let alone, that the mind itself can exist too, based on the use of ideas. In addition, these ideas have innate qualities that allow you to recognize or even label other tangible objects outside of the human body. Not to forget that your mind can work and create innate ideas independently of your body. Do I really need to use any part of my body (including senses) to make octopuppies? I obviously cannot create an octopuppie using my body, since it is logically impossible to make tentacles or flesh of one. Maybe using genetic engineering (gene splicing) that could become a reality, if Doctor Young wants to lobby Washington to make it happen.
15. Descartes tries to use the wax as a way to prove innate ideas. This is the complete opposite of Plato’s argument that innate ideas are unreliable to be used for knowledge. Therefore, Descartes takes the solid piece of wax and explores it through his senses. He is able to understand the properties (smell, texture, color, etc) after playing with it for a while. Then the wax is moved near the fireplace, which causes it to melt. As it melts, the wax properties change completely during the transition. Therefore, the melted wax has nothing in common with the solid wax at this point. Therefore, Descartes realizes that it is unreliable in using your senses to identify the wax. Hence, he says the innate ideas are the only way to determine that it is wax, in spite of what physical condition it might be. This may sound like a silly use of Descartes Wax Argument, but this can be related to movie THE THING (1982) by the filmmaker John Carpenter. The movie takes place at a U.S. Scientific Outpost in Antarctica. An alien that can imitate all life-forms flawlessly (might even imitate a octopuppie) penetrates the Outpost. It eventually disguises itself as one of the humans at the Outpost. The others discover the presence of the alien, but cannot use their senses in detecting who it is. Only with innate ideas, they can flush out the alien altogether. If you have not seen that film yet, then either rent it on Netflix or buy it on Amazon, a classic piece of sci-fi indeed!
16. Descartes concept of perfection originates in the mind. Yet, perfection could not be obtained through other means because not everything in the world including him is perfect. Therefore, perfection has to have come from an innate idea. He uses reason in determining what could be categorized as perfect. So the “perfect being” that he states can only be the existence of God. Thus creating a bridge between philosophy and religion. I think that perfect is a flawed innate idea. Does it have to be dependent on the idea of something being flawless? And why would God be considered a perfect being despite that his/her creations (human beings) are capable of doing imperfect actions? Moreover, why would humanity use it as a standard for which people cannot reach?
17. Descartes begins by saying that the physical world cannot exist, since our senses can be tricked into believing there is one. But Descartes then reverses himself with rationalism, which states some sensory information can be reliable enough to use. This raises an interesting question for me to ask about this process. Why do we have senses for anyway? What is the purpose in having them for in life? It seems that we need senses as a form of interaction with the world. Wouldn’t interaction be counted as a form of knowledge?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Hi Jeremy.
ReplyDeleteHere are some limited comments on your answers. To study for the final, I want you to go through the course materials to find out the specific tells that you have missed in your answers. When you tackle this section on the final, I want you to pay particular attention to what Descartes is actually saying, and leave out ideas about what you think b is motivations were.
11. Good overview of Descartes' method and intentions. However, you need to emphasize that Descartes will not accept any proposition that allows even the slightest doubt. If it can be doubted, it cannot count as knowledge. This is key. He created the idea of the evil genius to make it clear to people that, even if they could not see any reasonable reason to doubt a commonly accepted proposition, such as the existence of the world, it still logically could be false.
12. I like the phrase "marry doubt with reason," but I want to emphasize that one of Descartes's principles was that reason necessarily includes doubt. If doubt and reason are divorced, then there is no reason. And again, Descartes method holds that if that is any doubt at all, that proposition cannot be accepted. Your answer comes close, but it falls short because you do not include as your last sentence something like, "and if there's any chance at all that something is false, then that thing absolutely cannot be accepted."
13. Your answer here is way off. Everything you say here applies only to the problem with the senses, and says nothing about mathematics. Think of Descartes as a disembodied mind doing sums in his head. He has no senses, and he is not looking at mathematical formulas on pieces of paper. Instead, he's just thinking about math. Descartes's claim is that even in his own reasoning process, the evil genius could be tricking him about the results of mathematical calculations.
14. Your first sentence in is exactly right. However, begin to drift off the point as you go along. Descartes proves his existence as a mind. He does not prove the existence of anything else, and he certainly does not think that he can make things with his mind. Also, you don't understand innate ideas. Nobody makes innate ideas. They are built into your mind when you start to exist. Descartes never says that ideas have innate qualities, and he is not using ideas to label objects outside of the body.
15. Although you get Plato wrong, the rest of this answer is excellent. I really like your use of the movie to illustrate your understanding of Descartes's point. However, I would have liked more detail about how Descartes gets gets from "it could not have come from the senses" to "it must be an innate idea." This is a crucial part of the argument, and deserves a lot of explanation. Something you might want to think about is how did the scientists identify people as being the alien? Did they really use innate ideas? Or did they use some kind of sensory information?
16. I like your answer to number sixteen, although it is a bit short. But your questions are excellent, and I think you put your finger on a number of flaws in Descartes's argument.
17. Descartes has a long, elaborate argument starting with the cogito, building to the existence of god, and then deriving the existence of the world from the idea of gods perfection. To reconstruct this argument, start with the idea that god exists and is perfect, and then think about the issue of whether or not such a being would be a deceiver or allow a deceiver to exist.
Well done. Full marks.