Monday, April 27, 2009

Rene Descartes: Part 3

18. Cartesian Dualism basically refutes the concept of physicalism. Meaning that any existence of matter (rock, metal, water, etc) that cannot be experience in reality. Let alone, that the mind itself has no matter, energy, mass-energy, or laws of physics associated to it. Descartes believed that the mind was unique in relation to the body. Hence the premise of “dualistic,” that multiple kinds of material can exist. As well as the “essence” concept when it comes to identifying the mind and body. In other words, you try to find the properties that are in communication with the object. For example, let’s try to find properties with the pen that I'm using to write the answers for this question. Let see…it has plastic, ink, metal point, round shaft, removable cap, and printed logo. Perhaps the ink thing might be the essence of the pen? Descartes says that the essence of the mind is through and the body is space. And that the mind-body has nothing in common with each other. Thus both can exist independently to their overall relationship.

19. The so called “problem” with the mind-body is not about creating a solution for the concept. But Descartes then claim that the mind and body are connected to each other. This lead to a logical contradiction to Cartesian Dualism that claims that it’s the complete opposite of one another. Or how can the mind (immaterial) control the body (material) in the first place? And it almost sounds like Begging the Question by the lack of an answer from Descartes. So let me ask this question about the mind in particular. When he talks about “the mind,” is it about the brain (organ) itself? Or is it about other aspects of the brain such as the consciousness/sub-consciousness? If that’s the case, it seems like a 50/50 situation in regards to being either material or non-material. Maybe Descartes assumed more on the consciousness/sub-consciousness part perhaps?

20. Physicalism is a concept about any kind of thing that can be seen, felt, picked up. There were ideas on what to call the thing which leads to the word “matter.” Later on it changed to “materialism” as a way to say that matter can exist. This also distinguishes the notion that supernatural beings cannot exist because they’re not made of matter. But supernatural forces were mistakenly categorized as being until Einstein claimed that those forces (energy) were matter since they obeyed the laws of physics. Physicalism would make sense on earth, but what about the confines of outer space? Is a vacuum like a black hole considered matter? Logically, black holes are anti-matter, since it can break down matter in a heartbeat. Is celestial beings matter too, or is it just patterns of gas? I think it all boils down to the characteristics in terms of dimensional qualities that should be look at to determine if it is matter or not?

1 comment:

  1. Good work Jeremy, I appreciate how hard you're working on this.

    I should point out that the word "refutes" means "proves wrong." Descartes does not refute physicalism. He denies it, but he does not prove it wrong. Apart from that, I think you understand dualism correctly.

    When Descartes talks about the mind, he is most definitely not talking about the brain. For Descartes, the brain has nothing to do with thought. Descartes had no idea about a distinction between conscious and subconscious. He thought that something could exist without any material properties whatsoever. He thought the mind could exist completely independently of brain, so that if your brain was destroyed your mind could go on as if nothing had happened.

    Terminologically, the word "materialism" came before "physicalism." Logically, black holes are not anti-matter. They are normal matter. According to physicalism, celestial beings cannot exist. If physicalism is true, Cartesian dualism absolutely cannot be true.

    ReplyDelete