Sunday, May 10, 2009

Unit 6: George Berkeley

1. Berkeley believed that objects exist based more on the perception of the mind, rather that the old school method of matter. Meaning that an individual person just cannot accept an object “as is.” And what I mean by the term “as is” has to do with the outside the human mind and body. Instead, your perceptions of an object are what make it exist from your perspective. So what does it mean to perceive something? The typical definition of the word in the dictionary quotes things like “observe, recognize, understand, etc.” So to perceive is to analysis an object through a certain process. But what do we use in order to analysis it? The only logical possibility would be the senses themselves.

2. Berkeley thought that trying to refer to objects as “real” or “material” was confusing and pointless. Since he claims that our only real experiences of objects throughout our lives comes directly from perceptions. And that we should refer to saying the term “perceived objects” is more appropriate in that manner. So that we can describe it through details and descriptions. Let me give an example with this printed piece of paper in front of me. My perceptions are that it has square edges, mostly white with black type letters on the surface. It has a smooth texture with rough edges. But my mind also perceives it as light and crumpled based on the appearance. So would appearance be the key word to perception?

3. He states that the existence of other people all depend on something known as “objective.” What does it mean to be “objective?” The dictionary says “having actual existence outside the mind.” But obviously this is too vague an explanation. What about combining both of the words to form “perceived objective?” Afterall, you can analysis a person based on your observations, while taking into consideration their existence outside of your mind. Couldn’t this provide some sort of balance or a bridge in figuring out what exists and what doesn’t?

4. I think that Berkeley notices other people’s perceptions are similar to his own in many ways. He knew that other people have asked the same questions independently of himself. Thus when he talks about “speak to him” is when people share their insights about the world. And that they used the same type of perceptions gives a consistent answer in the process. Put it this way; let’s say that you go to a Bar on a Saturday alone. Then later you mingle with other people that you’ve never see before. You have perceptions about what makes a good relationship in your mind. But another person speaks about that subject first by giving their insights as well. And you realize that his/her insights are similar to yours. Thus providing the consistency that Berkeley mentions.

5. Berkeley overall views are that the presence of God is the perquisite for all of our life experiences to take place. Then he uses the analogy that God is a tree growing in a quadrangle at a University (humanity and the world.) And that the tree continues to exist despite of the people’s presence of it. Hence God has an infinite mind that can perceive everything. Forgive me for using some Logic for a moment. But do God and a tree really go together? God is an immortal divine being, and a tree is a mortal organism. God would have supernatural powers, while the tree is an immobile object. God creates life and the universe (supposedly,) and the tree creates leaves, bark, and oxygen. Do these two things really have anything in common at this point? Sounds like a False Analogy if you ask me!

6. Dr. Johnson who was infuriated by Berkeley’s theory kicked a heavy stone followed by the quote “I refute it thus!” Claiming that this physical activity proves the existence based on his perceptions. Dr. Johnson fails to realize that what the stone consisted of in reality was different in the construction of its perception. In other words, it was an idea that originated in the mind pure and simple. Besides, you can’t just kick a stone and expect to prove your point just like that. Sounds like a combination if Begging the Question, and insecurities to accepting a new theory.

7. Locke perceived that a primary quality is more of a physical characteristic of the substance itself. Compared to the secondary quality is more of a sensorial perception of the object. Not to forget that a secondary quality end up augmenting, but isn’t part of the objects substance altogether.

8. Locke uses three buckets of water which are cold, lukewarm, and hot. He says to put one hand into the cold and the other hand into the hot buckets. Then a few moments later put both hands in the lukewarm bucket. Both of your hand (objects) should determine if the water is “Hot or Cold,” but you find out that the water is both “Hot and Cold” at the same time. This basically points out that the temperature is a temporary characteristic that can easily change from one to another. As to why Locke says this count as a secondary quality of the water.

9. Berkeley extends primary qualities in the similar fashion of Locke. He points out that shape is a secondary quality because the size depends on the distance between the observer and the object. The difference in size can easily change, much like the temperature of the water in the buckets. But then Berkeley goes all out and refutes shape because he says it is neither primary nor secondary qualities.

10. Personality, I still don’t think that God can exist despite the perceiving part or not. This also reminds me of those Ghost Hunters reality TV Shows. And there attempts to perceive the existence of ghosts. But they put too much emphasis due to the fact that they’re dependent on finding ghosts. What about other factors that can mislead your perceptions of something. Let’s say that one of this Ghost Hunter’s walk into certain of a room and feel increased heat and start to get sweaty. Could that experience be perceived as a Ghost? What if you were standing near a heat vent? Or had hot-flashes? Or the room has poor ventilation or is over-insulation? IF those are the cases, then it seems more like secondary qualities. Since it’s just a temporary event, and not part of the permanent markup of that phenomenon. So what Berkeley says he perceives God as a present entity, what does he specifically perceive in order to make that happen?

11. Maybe our perceptions of humanity and the world around us serve as an example to figure out what life is all about. Since us humans have a tendency to experience and analysis our lives in an innate fashion. We’re all trying to understand our existence and purpose from an individual’s Point-Of-View. Here’s a random question: What if the shape of the human body and the personality of the mind end up as a universal law or quality? And when we perceive other people that it might become a mirror of some sort? And that we see ourselves through others in this manner? Well, this is my best guess to this million dollar question on philosophy for now.

1 comment:

  1. Good work 20/20.


    1. I like the way you analyze Berkeley's view of existence and perception. You really thought it through to its logical conclusion. Well done.

    2. Yes, appearance would be the key word to perception. Our perception of a thing is the way it appears to us.

    3. Going to the dictionary is always dangerous. The phrase "having actual existence outside the mind" is not vague at all. If I ask you to think of a forty pound tuna, and you do so, you will have a mental image of a fish. This image will only exist inside your mind. It will have no actual existence outside the mind. If I take an actual tuna out of a tank and thrust it into your hands, the forty pounds of squirming wet scaly fish will have actual existence outside of your mind. Not vague at all.

    4. Your account of going to the bar starts off well, but then veers off into a totally different issue. Berkeley is not talking about agreeing with someone about what makes a good relationship. (And people radically disagree about that.) A better example would be thinking about how many people both of you see in the bar. If you are both in a position to see everyone, and there's not too many people in the bar, you would be able to agree on a number. If, both being in exactly the same position and seeing exactly the same people, you disagree about the number of people in the bar, then your experiences will be inconsistent.

    5. The idea of the tree is not a metaphor for god. Berkeley just as that the tree continues to exist, even when no human is perceiving it, because god perceives it while no one else does.

    6. You can sometimes prove a point just by kicking a stone. If somebody said "stones cannot be correct," it would prove that person wrong if you kicked a stone. I'm not sure what you mean by "Doctor Johnson fails to realize that what the stone consisted all in reality was different in the construction of its perception." Berkeley would say that the stone just is all of its perceptions. To be is to be perceived. Johnson failed to refute Berkeley because Berkeley could still analyze Johnson's experience purely in terms of sense-data.

    7. Good.

    8. Lock pointed out that the same body of water felt cold to one hand and warm to the other. The same thing cannot be both hot and cold, so it follows that heat and coolness are not actually in objects. This has nothing to do with temperature the temporary.

    9. Good.

    10. The problem with Berkeley is that he claims that things that cannot be perceived do not exist. By this logic, dogs, which cannot be perceived, does not exist.

    11. I'm really not sure what you're trying to say here, but I don't think it has anything to do with Berkeley.

    ReplyDelete