1. Wikipedia interprets Descartes quote it as the core principle is that one must seek not only to build on old foundations of knowledge, but should look for other fertile land to build knowledge upon. My interpretation of the quote has to do with acknowledging. In addition, the word “conduct” refers to how to go about recognizing it. The second part “and learned upon principles which, in my youth, I had taken upon trust” has to do with learning how to think at an early age (childhood.) And that its very easy to be fooled during that period since your mind is a blank slate which lacks the ability to determine what’s right and wrong. Moreover, that we have to “trust” the adults’ principles as is, meaning that you accept the basic norms of thinking without thinking about it thoroughly. The main flaw with the Wikipedia interpretation assumes that it is about knowledge alone. They fail to realize that thinking and knowledge are two separate, rather than just one subject. This reminds me of the old Greek metaphor about the archer and the bull’s-eye. The archer represents a person and their thinking process, while the bull’s-eye represents knowledge. If the archer cannot see (think) the bull’s-eye with a clean and precise perspective, chances are he/she will either miss or inaccurately hit the bull’s-eye. So the process is more important than the principles overall.
2. The first precept has to do with doubt itself. That you do not accept something without fully understanding what it is. Anything that has a lot of doubt tends to be more problematic than useful. Therefore, their needs to be a fine line between what is doubtful and certain when it comes to establishing knowledge. The second precept has to do with taking something apart is sections with the difficulties to have a solution. Logically, this makes sense because it is easier to get more specific on what those difficulties are, and to take the next step. The third precept is to find the simplest problem and start from that point. In addition, you keep ascending until you reach the complex ones. Finally, the fourth precept, which is to take all the information at relay it to lists, tables, and diagrams. To get all your ducks in a row so the information is complete.
3. It seems that personal life experiences are the link between religion and the scientific method. Descartes provides the example through his actions. He takes things for granted with Catholicism until the death of his daughter. Then he had doubts about the church since they act so absolute about life and the world in general. Descartes decides to question things more critically that leads to more better techniques and processes.
4. The great controversy has to do with the lack of balances between faith and reason. In addition, the Descartes action to break with Catholic doctrine possibly alienates the religious community. This created two camps (religion versus science) that to this day still try to claim the ultimate truth. From my perspective your always going to have people on both sides who are hardcore, and lack an open mind towards other possibilities. This reminds me of the saying “if both eyes are too concentrated on one are, you lose sight of all other areas in the process.”
5. Descartes Cartesian method threatened the monopoly of the church power during that period. This resulted in the constant debate between faith and reason that leads to more thoughts that are modern. His method became such an epidemic for society that moved people away from religion and more towards secularism. Nevertheless, this also created a number of religious fundamental groups who use extreme measures to prove their premises, which results in death and destruction.
6. The word modernity seems more of a trendy and even a bit of a façade when it comes to an explanation of the modern period. Is there really such a thing as “modernity?” Sounds like more about being Politically Correct than giving an accurate comparison. A better one would be progressive and traditionalism. Progressive is all about evolving in thought and not taking things for granted. Compared to traditionalism, where old ideas and methods are preserved from past scholars, establishments, and doctrines. However, the only trap of traditionalism is that people stop questioning and assume those ideas. Especially with the case of religion, since it’s all about complying with an ideology, regardless of the flaws and shortcomings in it.
7. Shorto’s thinks that the modest proposal to ground knowledge has to do with human reason, and that the Cartesian method was the basis for the scientific method and the reason-based political philosophy of the Enlightenment. First off, what is this so called “ground knowledge?” The word ground could imply established, but what is established specifically? It looks a little on the Begging the Question side so far. Moreover, why does Shorto keep thinking that Descartes was responsible for the Scientific Method? If we can review the past philosophers from this online class, it was Galileo who came up with the Scientific Method going back over two centuries. In addition, we can go further back a couple of Millennia with Aristotle too. Descartes ended up augmenting the Scientific Method with new idea only.
8. Latin was the primary dialect of the Catholic Church. Chances are if it were published in Latin, it would have interference with the church, maybe either being censored or parts of it omitted like past philosophers. Another has to do with the scholars’ verses society. If scholars have a tendency to discuss knowledge only among them then it would stay within that elite group of people. By publishing it in French allow the Discourse to be circulated on a massive scale that puts copies in the hands of individuals to comprehend and question their society. Therefore, the social effect of this tipped the balance of power away from the Status Quo, gave new ways on how to think, analysis, and distinguished what is truthful in relation to doubt.
9. Shorto’s interpretation tends to focus the examples of Descartes, in particular of the failures and tragedy of his life. He claims that the death of Descartes daughter became a revelation on how to look at the role of the nature of human beings. Realizing that all previous knowledge was unreliable, Descartes uses doubt as a tool to test in search of truth. And the thinking process (I think, therefore I am) he created made people be less dependent on the church in seeking answers.
10. Overall, Shorto’s views and arguments with Descartes are pithy in relation to the whole picture of this philosopher. Shorto tends to focus too much on the personal side along with the aftermath of his remains. Trying to make it into a romantic melodrama type story instead of getting down to the nitty-gritty rational details of Descartes theories. Even the part about where and how Descartes bones ended up decades after his death is very unfortunate ending. Scientist and Philosophers treating the bones and especially the skull as if they were sacred and profane objects, WTF Man! Descartes was a Great Philosopher for his time, but he was not a Divine being! If there is a blotch in the history of Science, this affair could be counted as one. Talking about superstition all over again, yikes!
"Latin was the primary dialect of the Catholic Church. Chances are if it were published in Latin, it would have interference with the church..."
ReplyDeleteI never thought about it that way! Thanks. So now this brings up another thought. What if you take the second part of your answer, of putting it in the hands of many people rather than the few, and then come up with, perhaps, of Descartes purposely doing it to soften the blow of the impact it would have if it was only published in Latin. If it was only in Latin, the Church could deal with it swiftly; but in French, they would have to take a more cautionary approach, as it would be in the hands of the masses. And they don't really know who the masses are, but they would know many of the "intellectuals". This is all just speculation though.
Jeremy, your interpretation of the quote is interesting, but failing to realize that thinking and knowledge are two separate subjects would only be a flaw in the Wikipedia interpretation if Descartes made reference to this distinction in the quotation. I don't see him saying anything about the difference between thinking and knowledge. He is writing about methodology, and in the quotation he explicitly rejects the idea that people before him have created a foundation for knowledge. He is saying that the methods used before him are faulty, and he is not going to use them. The flaw in the Wikipedia interpretation is that Wikipedia says he is going to use his new method as well as the old methods, when in fact he is going to use it instead of the old methods. His whole point is that the old methods suck.
ReplyDeleteI would like you to try to be a little more precise in how you use the terms "faith" and "reason." Faith is precisely defined as believing things on the basis of personal choice without any attention to logic or evidence, and reason is precisely defined as using logic and evidence to determine what your beliefs should be. The conflict between elements of the church and elements of the scientific community was not always a conflict between faith and reason.
Jeremy, "modernity" is the name for the period of time characterized by the dominance of rational methods of thought. We don't need to worry about whether this is a good or bad name, and it is neither trendy nor a façade. Introducing different terminology at this point will only confuse things. Apart from that, your comments about "progressive" makes sense when applied to modernity.
You make good points about Shorto's analysis.
Overall, very good work.
Doctor Young.